Categories General Red Sox Deposing the Bard Post author By Paul SF Post date March 18, 2009 14 Comments on Deposing the Bard Josh Bard is out. Is someone else in, or is it George Kottaras' time to shine? ← The Wright Stuff → World’s Biggest Cockup 14 replies on “Deposing the Bard” it makese sense, they brought Bard on in case something didn’t happen with Tek – Kottaras is out of options, and a much better hitter from the left side. Plus he caught Zink in the minors – albeit a different knuckler, still a knuckler… This makes no sense, unless: 1. The Sox are about to acquire Teagarden or Salty 2. The Sox are getting ready to release Wakefield as well 3. Josh Bard slept with Francona’s wife I don’t think Kottaras is ready, and I don’t think this is the full news. Give it a day or two and I’m sure there will be another piece to the puzzle that makes this move make sense. somewhere dougie mirabelli just kicked an empty pizza box off the bed and chuckled to himself. no way would the sox release Wake (he may retire at their urging, but they wouldn’t dump him). – I think Bard was insurance for Tek, now that Tek is there, go with the younger, cheaper catcher as backup and let the season unfolds and see what is needed. (he may retire at their urging, but they wouldn’t dump him). That’s essentially what I meant. I still don’t think Kottaras is ready for a full season as a major-league backup catcher, and I was under the impression that he struggled to catch Wake as well. I guess we’ll have to wait and see. I watched the game, he did a good job catching Wake IIRC, I remember one ball getting by him, but he seemed to handle things pretty well. Ahh, I haven’t seen him catch Wake at all, I was just going off of what I had heard from others. I hope he does okay, I just think that he hasn’t matured enough as a hitter. I still don’t think Kottaras is ready for a full season as a major-league backup catcher I am trying to assimilate what a low level of suck this statement describes. SF is correct. Even the most pessimistic projection — PECOTA’s — has Kottaras outperforming Cash, and significantly outslugging him. Bard and Varitek each have the same platoon splits, while Kottaras is essentially even, but has better slugging against righties. So if this is an indication the Sox are moving toward a platoon scenario with Tek and Kottaras, this is a very promising move indeed. The combined output of a lefties-only Tek and righties-only Kottaras would actually be quite impressive, given the position. That’s the right move. It’s now or never for Kottaras and unless they were cutting Varitek, it had to be Bard. Still, Bard or Varitek? I expect Bard to have the better season and, worse for the Sox, I don’t expect Kottaras to start more than 60 games, unless there’s an injury to Varitek. It may be too soon for Kottaras, but the SOx had no choice. Still, Bard right now is probably the best of the bunch. He just wasn’t going to be catching a knuckler. The combined output of a lefties-only Tek and righties-only Kottaras would actually be quite impressive, given the position. So that means Varitek starting only once or twice a week? I don’t see that unless he’s teh suck again. Word. I’m happy George is finally going to get a little game time, and in a nicely low-pressure circumstance too. Let’s see what we have on our hands before losing a Bowden to get a Texas catcher. You mean a Buchholz. I think the Pecota projections should be taken with a few grains of skepticism since Kottaras has only five major-league at-bats. I would love to be wrong, but I personally think he’ll totally suck this year, even if used mostly against righties. Rob makes a great point about Varitek too; I just don’t see him playing in only ~50 games this season. I’m calling it now: Varitek will OPS+ 110, and Kottaras will be traded/released/thrown-into-a-volcano by June. Like I said I’d love to be wrong, but I’m just not high on Kottaras, despite any projections. I freely admit that there’s no proof to this assertion, and that it’s just my gut feeling. Comments are closed.