Dissent in the Ranks

In a recent post on his Futility Infielder site, Jay Jaffe argues that Mel Stottlemyre has become the “sacred cow” of the Yankee organization, that his charges have a history of developing arm trouble, incoming talent has a habit of degenerating on his watch, and that he’s not had much success in helping players fix their mechanics. (Actually, Jaffe has been making these arguments for some time, but Allen Barra recently picked them up in a piece for the NY Sun.) Writes Jaffe: “The bottom line is that Yankee fans ought to assume the crash position. When this pitching staff goes over the cliff, don’t expect Mel Stottlemyre to be the one to pull it up to safety.”

Elsewhere, a post entitled “Mismanagement 101” on the Replacement Level Yankee blog catalogues a series of questionable managerial decisions and concludes, “I think it’s time for the Joe Torre era to end, whether they win or lose this year. He’s had a great run, and I thank him for that, but he’s becoming more and more detrimental to this team’s chances every year.”

Is this Yankee Golden Age over? Is a new administration the answer? Unpleasant questions to ponder.

3 comments… add one
  • I gotta say, Tiger Wang has a pretty nice, fluid pitching motion, and his stuff appears to move nicely. Who knows what happens the second time through the lineup, or, if it comes to it, a second time through the league, but he looks like a serviceable pitcher. Yankees fans should be pleasantly surprised, at least through three.

    SF April 30, 2005, 2:52 pm
  • It was a very nice outing, right up until Tom Gordon came on to give away his W. How many games does he need to blow before a few of the other relievers in the 13-man Yankee staff get some time in the set-up slot?

    YF April 30, 2005, 4:21 pm
  • I think Torre has made mistakes, but to say it’s time for him to go, people will write just about anything. Morons.

    MFY Fan May 1, 2005, 7:24 pm

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.