I finally had the chance to review the Matsuzaka Contract Pool thread, and have reluctantly come up with a winner. I say "reluctantly" because we pretty much all missed the boat. Scott Boras played us for fools, scaring us into thinking big money for big years. The only person to call his bluff was Theo Epstein, and it would now appear that he doesn’t post at YFSF, at least not during sensitive negotiations (I hear he occasionally pipes in during discussions about Tito’s batting order, though).
Anyhow, the "winner" (tough word, that) is (reluctantly):
I know, I know. He didn’t put any numbers down. And I know he’s a proprietor of the site. But he did call the deal correctly, and for the right reasons. But he gets no YFSF goodies, since he owns the place. Feel free to attack me in the comments for my inflammatory decision. ;-)